Timothy S. Gross
Mike Meyer
2005
Ecological Risk Assessment of Toxic Substances in the Greater Everglades Ecosystem: Wildlife Effects and Exposure Assessment
http://sofia.usgs.gov/projects/eco_risk/
This project will be carried out in several locations throughout those areas critical to the South Florida Restoration Initiative. These areas include: 1) Water Conservation Areas 1, 2, and 3 of the Central Everglades, 2) Everglades National Park, 3) Loxahatchee National Wildlife Refuge, 4) Big Cypress National Preserve, 5) multiple Miami Metropolitan area canals and drainages, and 6) restoration related STA’s (STA’s 1-6) adjacent to the Everglades. Specific site selections will be based upon consideration of USACE restoration plans and upon discussions with other place-based and CESI approved projects.
The overall objectives are characterize the exposure of wildlife to contaminants within the aquatic ecosystems of South Florida, through a multi-stage process: a) screening of biota to identify hazards/contaminants posing risk, and b) evaluation of the potential effects of those contaminants on appropriate animal/wildlife receptors. This project will focus upon each of these stages/needs, with an emphasis on understanding the effects of contaminants on alligators, fishes, birds, amphibians and macroinvertebrates.
Historically, little consideration has been given to environmental chemical stressors/contaminants within the ecosystem restoration efforts for the Greater Everglades Ecosystem. The restoration is primarily guided by determining and restoring the historical relationships between ecosystem function and hydrology. The restoration plan was formulated to restore the natural hydrology and therefore, the resultant landscape patterns, bio-diversity and wildlife abundance. However, additional efforts need to consider the role that chemical contaminants such as pesticides and other inorganic/organic contaminants play in the structure and function of the resultant South Florida ecosystems. Indeed, the current level of agriculture and expanding urbanization and development necessitate that more emphasis be placed on chemical contaminants within this sensitive ecosystem and the current restoration efforts.
The primary goal of the proposed project, therefore, is to develop an improved understanding of the exposure/fate (i.e. degradation, metabolism, dissipation, accumulation and transport) and potential ecological effects produced as a result of chemical stressors and their interactions in South Florida freshwater and wetland ecosystems. The overall objectives are to evaluate the risk posed by contaminants to biota within the aquatic ecosystems of South Florida, through a multi-stage process: a) screening of biota to identify hazards/contaminants posing risk and b) evaluation of the potential effects of those contaminants on appropriate animal/wildlife receptors. This project will focus upon each of these stages/needs, with an emphasis on understanding the effects of contaminants on alligators, fishes, birds, amphibians and macroinvertebrates.
The specific objectives of this project are to:
1. Assess current exposure and potential adverse effects for appropriate receptors/species within the South Florida ecosystems with some emphasis on DOI trust species. These efforts will determine whether natural populations are significantly exposed to a variety of chemical stressors/contaminants, such as mercury, chlorinated hydrocarbon pesticides, historic and/or current use agricultural chemicals, and/or mixtures, as well as document lethal and non-lethal adverse effects in multiple health, physiologic and/or endocrine endpoints.
2. Assess exposure and potential adverse effects for appropriate species within South Florida as a function of restoration implementation.
20001001
20040930
ground condition
None planned
South Florida Ecosystem
-81.125
-80.125
26.75
25.125
none
biology
contaminants
ecological risk assessment
toxics
ISO 19115 Topic Category
biota
environment
inlandWaters
002
007
012
Department of Commerce, 1995, Countries, Dependencies, Areas of Special Sovereignty, and Their Principal Administrative Divisions, Federal Information Processing Standard (FIPS) 10-4, Washington, D.C., National Institute of Standards and Technology
United States
US
U.S. Department of Commerce, 1987, Codes for the identification of the States, the District of Columbia and the outlying areas of the United States, and associated areas (Federal Information Processing Standard 5-2): Washington, D. C., NIST
Florida
FL
Department of Commerce, 1990, Counties and Equivalent Entities of the United States, Its Possessions, and Associated Areas, FIPS 6-3, Washington, DC, National Institute of Standards and Technology
Broward County
Palm Beach County
Miami-Dade County
Monroe County
Collier County
none
Central Everglades
Florida Keys
SW Big Cypress
South East Coast
Water Conservation Area 1
Water Conservation Area 2
Water Conservation Area 3
WCA1
WCA2
WCA3
STA 5
Storm Treatment Areas
STA 1
STA 3
STA 4
STA 6
STA 2
USGS Geographic Names Information System
Everglades National Park
Big Cypress National Preserve
Loxahatchee National Wildlife Refuge
none
multiple species
animals
reptiles
vertebrates
U.S. Department of Agriculture - Agricultural Research Service (ARS)
U.S. Department of Agriculture - Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS)
Department of the Interior - U.S. Geological Survey
Department of Commerce - National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
Smithsonian Institution - National Museum of Natural History (NMNH)
2000
Integrated Taxonomic Information System (ITIS)
Database
Retrieved from the Integrated Taxonomic Information System on-line database, http://www.itis.gov.
http://www.itis.gov
Alligators were collected at six sites throughout the south Florida/Everglades ecosystem. Contaminant analyses and preliminary assessments of potential effects included a full survey/assessment of freshwater mussels in historic locations throughout south Florida. Additional assessments of wading birds and other species will be conducted.
unknown
All specimens were identified to the species level
Kingdom
Animalia
animals
Phylum
Chordata
chordates
Subphylum
Vertebrata
vertebrates
Class
Reptilia
reptiles
Order
Crocodilia
crocodiles
alligators
caimans
Family
Alligatoridae
alligators
Genus
Alligator
alligators
Species
Alligator mississippiensis
American alligator
Florida alligator
Class
Aves
birds
Order
Ciconiiformes
ibises
Family
Threskiornithidae
ibises
spoonbills
Genus
Eudocimus
white ibises
Species
Eudocimus albus
white ibis
Order
Ciconiiformes
herons
Family
Ardeidae
bitterns
egrets
herons
Genus
Casmerodius
great egrets
species
Casmerodius albus
great egret
Superclass
Osteichthyes
bony fishes
Class
Actinopterygii
ray-finned fishes
spiny rayed fishes
Subclass
Neopterygii
Infraclass
Teleostei
Superorder
Ostariophysi
Order
Siluriformes
catfishes
Family
Ictaluridae
bullhead catfishes
Genus
Ameiurus
bullheads
Species
Ameiurus nebulosus
brown bullhead
Superorder
Acanthopterygii
Order
Perciformes
perch-like fishes
Suborder
Percoidei
Family
Centrarchidae
sunfishes
Genus
Micropterus
black basses
largemouth basses
Species
Micropterus salmoides
largemouth bass
Phylum
Mollusca
molluscs
mollusks
Class
Gastropoda
gastropods
snails
slugs
Subclass
Prosobranchia
Order
Architaenioglossa
Family
Ampullariidae
Genus
Pomacea
Species
Pomacea paludosa
Florida apple snail
Phylum
Mollusca
molluscs
mollusks
Class
Bivalvia
bivalves
Subclass
Palaeoheterodonta
Order
Unionoida
Family
Unionidae
Genus
Elliptio
Species
Elliptio buckleyi
Florida shiny spike
Genus
Utterbackia
Species
Utterbackis imbecillis
paper pondshell
none
none
Lynn Lefebvre
U.S. Geological Survey
mailing and physical address
2201 NW 40th Terrace
Gainesville
FL
32605
USA
352 264-3543
352 373-5763
llefebvre@usgs.gov
Project personnel included: Marisol Sepulveda, Jon Wiebe, Carla Wieser, Nicola Kernaghan, Shane Ruessler, and Beverly Arnold
not applicable
not available
Efforts during FY2000 have involved the collection of alligators at 6 sites throughout the South Florida/Everglades ecosystem. Contaminant analyses and preliminary assessments of potential effects are currently underway. These efforts have also included a full survey/assessment of freshwater mussels in historic locations throughout S. Florida. Complete analyses for invertebrates will be completed during Fall 2000. Additional survey/assessments of fish throughout the South Florida ecosystems is currently underway and will occur throughout Fall 2000. Additional assessments of wading birds are proposed for Spring 2000, as well as additional assessments of other species and the completion of preliminary risk assessments.
2000
We have conducted a survey of freshwater mussels across 32 sites, alligators across 14 sites, and largemouth bass and sunfish for 42 sites. Efforts are now in progress and/or planned for amphibians at 12 sites and wading birds (i.e. great egrets) at 5 sites. Alligator tissues are complete for OC and target contaminant analyses; however, analyses of non-classic/non-target compounds such as pharmaceuticals etc are currently underway. These causes significant exposures for alligators in WCA’s and other restored/reclaimed sites, as well as exposure to historic and current use agricultural and urban-runoff chemical contaminants. Fish samples have been collected from an extensive collection of sites during the non-reproductive season and analyses are in progress. Initial analyses suggest significant exposures and significant distribution differences across S. Florida ecosystems. Fish efforts have been in collaboration with the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission and the South Florida Water Management District. Amphibian surveys and collections are currently underway and will be ongoing through Spring 2003. These efforts are in collaboration with Ken Rice and with the University of Florida-IFAS and Syngenta, Corp. Initial efforts to identify colonies of wading birds are underway and collections will occur during 2003-2004.
2001
We have conducted a survey of amphibians (frogs and toads at 12 sites) and wading birds (i.e. great egrets) at 5 sites. Fish samples have been collected from an extensive collection of sites during the non-reproductive season, mercury analyses are complete and OCP and other contaminant analyses are in progress. Initial analyses suggest significant exposures and significant distribution differences across S. Florida ecosystems and an altered distribution of mercury with the implementation of STA's. Fish efforts have been in collaboration with the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission and the South Florida Water Management District. Amphibian surveys and collections are complete and chemical analyses will be conducted during 2004-5
2002
Work planned for FY 2004 includes:
1. Assess current exposure and potential adverse effects for appropriate receptors/species within the South Florida ecosystems with some emphasis on DOI trust species
The initial exposure assessment will begin with an evaluation and expansion of data and the sample base generated by the preliminary phase of this project (2000-2002). These efforts have included the sampling of alligators, fish, amphibians and freshwater mussels across multiple sites in the Greater Everglades Ecosystem as an initiation of efforts to characterize exposure and effects. There are currently greater than 3000 biota samples banked for these analyses. Additional sampling regimes, will also be needed, at selected critical areas to provide an evaluation of soil, water and sediments and/or additional biota. These evaluations will include pH, percent water, grain size, cation exchange capacity, and total volatile solids as well as quantitation of organochlorine pesticides and polychlorinated biphenyls (PCB’s, polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), organophosphate pesticides (OPs), nitrogen based herbicides, phenoxy-acid herbicides, and heavy metals. Soil, sediment and water samples will be collected and analyzed at multiple seasons, 4-6 times annually, to assess temporal patterns in use, especially for the non-persistent, water-soluble, pesticides. Tissue samples will also be collected from the ecological receptors, outlined above, at many of these selected sites. Tissues will also be analyzed for lipid content, as well as quantitation of organochlorine pesticides and polychlorinated biphenyls (PCB’s, polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), organophosphate pesticides (OPs), nitrogen based herbicides, phenoxy-acid herbicides, and heavy metals. These efforts will enable the first complete exposure assessment at multiple trophic levels for the Greater Everglades ecosystem, and serve as a critical basis for all future research efforts and risk assessments.
In addition to the emphasis on the persistent contaminants listed above, we also propose the characterization of non-target, current use, non or less persistent contaminants as well. These contaminants have been identified as the emerging contaminants of concern for ecosystems throughout the US by USEPA. Analyses will include chemicals/contaminants of concern from urban run-off or waste water: pharmaceuticals, health care components, xenobiotic endocrine factors and current use pesticides, as well as nutrients and novel compounds. These contaminants have not been characterized for the Greater Everglades Ecosystem previously, nor have they been considered under any of the restoration strategies. The partnership with the WRD-Water Quality Laboratory in Ocala will be critical to these efforts and to the development of appropriate techniques to evaluate this emerging contaminant issue.
To assess whether chemical stressors/contaminants in South Florida harm wildlife (effects assessment) it is important to study animals that are potentially exposed and appear sensitive to contaminants. Utilization of several receptors/species at multiple trophic levels will enable the detection of both potential exposures and adverse effects within the South Florida ecosystems. The project will utilize American alligators, largemouth bass, brown-bullhead catfish, white ibises, great egrets, Florida apple snails, and two endemic species of freshwater mussels as model ecological receptors for evaluation of the South Florida ecosystems. Receptors will be monitored for acute and chronic effects, such as general health status, growth, development, reproduction, and endocrine function. These initial assessments will rely primarily upon biomarkers and bioindicators of effects, such as sex steroids, vitellogenin, stress hormones, thyroid hormones, blood chemistry, organ somatic indices, body condition indices, plasma and tissue lysozyme, and tissue glycogen.
20040930
Lynn Lefebvre
U.S. Geological Survey
mailing and physical address
2201 NW 40th Terrace
Gainesville
FL
32605
USA
352 264-3543
352 373-5763
llefebvre@usgs.gov
Lynn Lefebvre
U.S. Geological Survey
mailing and physical address
2201 NW 40th Terrace
Gainesville
FL
32605
USA
352 264-3543
352 373-5763
llefebvre@usgs.gov
ecological risk assessment papers
The USGS assumes no responsibility for the use of these data
unknown
none
Please contact Lynn Lefebvre for data from this project
20070123
Heather Henkel
U.S. Geological Survey
mailing and physical address
600 Fourth Street South
St. Petersburg
FL
33701
USA
727 803-8747 ext 3028
727 803-2030
sofia-metadata@usgs.gov
Content Standard for Digital Geospatial Metadata Part 1: Biological Data Profile
FGDC-STD-001.1-1999